ExpressVPN vs Avira Phantom VPN 2025

Agnieszka Stec Cybersecurity Researcher

Updated on 5th March 2025

ExpressVPN outperformed Avira Phantom VPN in nearly every category, so there’s little wonder that this service reports having over 4 million active subscribers¹. It boasts an independently audited no-logs policy, faster speeds, and advanced security features, while its competitor was far less reliable when it came to speed and privacy practices.

My team and I conducted extensive tests on both VPNs, evaluating their performance in streaming, gaming, torrenting, and more. We also closely examined their privacy policies, security features, and server infrastructure. Even though Avira Phantom VPN comes from a major antivirus company, we found it was severely lacking.

So, if you’re looking for the best VPN for your money, I recommend ExpressVPN. It provides excellent value and is suitable for both beginners and advanced users alike. While Avira Phantom VPN’s free plan is undoubtedly tempting, I can’t recommend using this service given its poor performance in our tests.

Try ExpressVPN Risk-Free

Short on Time? Here Are My Key Findings

Streaming — ExpressVPN Works With Considerably More Platforms

ExpressVPN is much better for streaming than Avira VPN. Avira Phantom VPN worked well for streaming with certain platforms, but there were a few it couldn’t safely access.

ExpressVPN could safely access far more streaming platforms, and it could do so far more reliably, too. We tried a variety of platforms, from global options like Netflix and Prime Video to regional ones like Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and ESPN. We could stream in the best possible quality on each one, and we had no buffering or lag issues.

Avira Phantom VPN was much less reliable for streaming than ExpressVPN. In our tests, it was not able to work with Disney+, Hulu, and BBC iPlayer. ExpressVPN constantly provides safe access to these platforms, so it’s possible to stream your favorite content in HD from anywhere.

ExpressVPN also offers a smart DNS feature called MediaStreamer. This allows you to stream on devices that don’t typically support VPNs, such as smart TVs and gaming consoles. MediaStreamer is compatible with several popular streaming services, but not all. A support representative confirmed that it currently supports Netflix, Max, Amazon Prime Video US, and BBC iPlayer.

Winner

Does ExpressVPN or Avira Phantom VPN have better streaming performance? ExpressVPN is much more reliable for streaming. With fast and stable connections and the ability to work with Hulu, Disney+, BBC iPlayer, and DAZN, it leaves Phantom VPN far behind. 

Server Network — ExpressVPN Has a Larger Server Network

ExpressVPN stands out because it offers much more extensive server coverage. It covers over three times more countries than Avira Phantom VPN, and the latter’s Asian and African coverage is very poor. Such a robust network minimizes the risk of overcrowded servers and usually contributes to faster speeds.

Additionally, ExpressVPN runs on RAM-only servers, which wipe your data on every reboot, ensuring your online activity stays private. Avira VPN doesn’t disclose information about its server type.

Winner

Which one is better for travelers, ExpressVPN or Avira Phantom VPN? ExpressVPN, as its extensive network of RAM-only servers covers far more countries, so you’ll always be able to find a fast, nearby server. 

Speed — ExpressVPN Takes the Lead With Faster Speeds

ExpressVPN delivered significantly faster speeds than Avira Phantom VPN on both nearby and distant servers. We conducted tests from a US location using servers in the US, UK, and Japan. For these tests, we used Lightway for ExpressVPN and OpenVPN for Avira Phantom VPN. It’s worth noting that our base speed was slightly lower when we tested Avira VPN.

On nearby servers, ExpressVPN delivered exceptional speeds, with an average of 152.88 Mbps across our tests. In contrast, Avira Phantom VPN averaged just 58.89 Mbps. In real terms, ExpressVPN’s speed drop was barely noticeable, but the larger drop from Avira did result in web pages taking longer to load.

The gap widened over longer distances. On a distant UK server, ExpressVPN maintained strong performance at 125.23 Mbps, while Avira Phantom VPN lagged behind at only 37.86 Mbps.

Winner

Which VPN performed better in our speed tests, ExpressVPN or Avira Phantom VPN? ExpressVPN was much faster and more reliable than Phantom VPN, largely thanks to its proprietary Lightway protocol and extensive server network.

Gaming — Both VPNs Are Good for Gaming on Nearby Servers

To determine which VPN is better for gaming, we tested how quickly a device communicates with a server—a metric known as ping, which is essential for gaming performance. For a lag-free experience, ping should stay below 100 ms.

Both VPNs performed well on nearby servers but struggled with higher ping on distant ones, which is typical for most VPNs. However, ExpressVPN’s ping was significantly lower in almost all cases. For the best gaming experience, we recommend connecting to the closest available server.

We never had any jittery movements or loading issues

Winner - draw

/

Which VPN works better for gaming, ExpressVPN or Avira Phantom VPN? Both VPNs are suitable for gaming on nearby servers but don’t work well on distant ones. ExpressVPN is generally faster and has more server locations, which makes it easier to find a server close by.

Torrenting — ExpressVPN Wins With Faster Download Speeds

Both VPNs support torrenting, but ExpressVPN stands out with faster speeds for speedy downloads. In our tests, we downloaded a 4 GB file was downloaded in just 40 seconds with ExpressVPN, whereas Avira Phantom VPN took over two minutes.

ExpressVPN also supports port forwarding via router setup, which can further improve speeds — a feature Avira Phantom VPN lacks. If you want to learn more, check out our guide to increasing your torrenting speeds.

Both VPNs passed leak tests, and neither showed any IPv6, DNS, or WebRTC leaks. However, ExpressVPN provides additional privacy features, including a kill switch on all devices and built-in ad and malicious site blocking. Torrenting sites are often packed with shady ads, so this can help speed up your browsing and keep you safe.

Winner

Which one offers better security for torrenting, ExpressVPN vs Avira Phantom VPN? ExpressVPN has more security features and includes a kill switch on all devices. It’s also faster and supports port forwarding via router setup. 

Security — ExpressVPN’s Feature Suite is Robust and Extensive

ExpressVPN once again takes the lead with a range of well-tested security features, including automatic obfuscation, an ad and malicious site blocker, and more. In comparison, Avira Phantom VPN provides standard security features like AES-256-GCM encryption but lacks additional advanced protection, like obfuscation and RAM-only servers.

ExpressVPN offers its proprietary Lightway protocol, which provides excellent speeds and strong security via 256-bit AES or ChaCha20 encryption — two of the strongest encryption algorithms available. Meanwhile, Avira Phantom VPN relies on IPsec (for iOS and Android), OpenVPN, and SSL/TLS (for macOS and Windows), which are older and generally more vulnerable to security risks.

You’ll also get far more robust features with ExpressVPN. Its built-in ad and tracker blocker, Advanced Protection, enhances security by blocking malicious websites and intrusive ads. It also includes Parental Controls to restrict access to adult content. While Avira Phantom VPN also blocks malicious sites, I found that ExpressVPN blocked far more ads, helping to speed up my browsing.

Unlike AviraVPN, ExpressVPN offers a dedicated IP feature. It can’t trace the dedicated IP you’re assigned back to you, maintaining high privacy standards. This feature is currently available as an optional add-on for Android, iOS, and Windows platforms, with plans to expand to more platforms in the future.

Winner

Which VPN is most trusted? ExpressVPN emerges as the most trusted VPN due to its robust security features. It’s more feature-rich and supports modern Lightway protocol, which contributes to better speeds and tighter security. 

Privacy — ExpressVPN Wins With Its Tested Privacy Policy

DemandSage reports that 80% of individuals use VPNs to enhance security and 66% to safeguard their data². We carefully examined both VPNs’ privacy policies to make sure your data is in the right hands.

Both VPNs claim to follow a strict no-logs policy to protect your privacy. However, only ExpressVPN has undergone several independent audits that verify these claims. It also demonstrated its commitment to privacy in 2017 when Turkish authorities seized one of its servers and found no user data.

Avira Phantom VPN’s privacy policy is brief. It states that it doesn’t collect information about the websites and services you use, nor does it track any information that can link you to your online activities. However, none of these claims are backed up by audits, which makes me question their legitimacy.

ExpressVPN is based in the privacy-friendly British Virgin Islands. Meanwhile, Avira Phantom VPN operates from Germany, a member of the 14 Eyes Alliance, which shares intelligence among member countries. Learn more about these intelligence-sharing alliances in our guide.

Winner

Does Avira Phantom VPN keep logs? No, Avira VPN claims not to keep any logs. However, this has not been verified by an independent company. That’s why ExpressVPN takes the win, as its no-logs policy has been extensively audited and its headquarters are based in a privacy-friendly jurisdiction. 

Works in China — ExpressVPN Usually Works, But Not Guaranteed

Few VPNs work in China due to its strict internet restrictions and advanced blocking systems. However, ExpressVPN is one of the more reliable options thanks to its automatic obfuscation technology, which disguises your VPN traffic as regular internet activity. However, like all VPNs in China, occasional connection issues may still occur, and it can’t guarantee 100% uptime.

ExpressVPN also provides ways to sign up from within China, which is not common among VPNs. Since the country blocks most VPN websites, it’s a good idea to install the app before arriving. However, ExpressVPN’s support team can provide a mirror URL to users outside China, which can then be shared with someone in the country to help with signing up.

In contrast, Avira Phantom VPN doesn’t work in China. Customer support confirmed that the VPN can’t connect within the country.

Winner

Is ExpressVPN owned by China? No, it doesn’t have any links with China. Thanks to its solid obfuscation technology, ExpressVPN is one of a few Western VPNs that still work in the country. 

Installation & Ease of Use — Both VPNs are User-Friendly

Both VPNs are user-friendly but have different designs - the better choice depends on your specific needs and preferences. ExpressVPN offers a well-balanced interface that combines simplicity with functionality. I like its main screen, which has a large connection button and the selected server location, with easy access to the server list.

In contrast, Avira Phantom VPN adopts a minimalist but slightly chunky design, providing only a few extra options in addition to the big connection button on the main screen. While this makes it easy for beginners to get started, it lacks many essential features that are standard in most VPNs.

Winner - draw

/

Which VPN is easier to set up and use, ExpressVPN or Avira VPN? Both services are quick to download and easy to set up. Avira VPN is as simple as it gets, with just a few features available. On the other hand, ExpressVPN’s apps are feature-rich but still very clear and intuitive.

Reliability & Support — ExpressVPN Wins With Live Chat

When I tested ExpressVPN’s live chat support with questions about its ad blocker and obfuscation, I connected with an agent quickly each time and received detailed, helpful responses.

Avira Phantom VPN, however, lacks live chat support — even for Pro users. I had to use its email-based ticketing system to ask Avira about its availability in China. My first support ticket was closed without explanation, forcing me to submit another request. I received an answer after around 16 hours, which isn’t ideal for a paid service.

Both VPNs offer comprehensive support resources, but ExpressVPN takes the lead with a large knowledge base, live chat, and video tutorials.

Winner

Which VPN has better customer support? ExpressVPN wins with 24/7 live chat and a more extensive knowledge base. It also has video tutorials, which is a big help in troubleshooting simple issues.

Pricing

	ExpressVPN	Avira Phantom VPN
Starting Price	$4.99/month	$5.99/month
Price (On Renewal)	$116.95 per year (subject to change)	$78 per year (subject to change)
Money-Back Guarantee (Days)	30 days	60 days
Number of Devices per License	8	Unlimited
Router Setup (for Unlimited Devices)	Easy setup with a dedicated firmware	No

Avira Phantom VPN is the more affordable option, offering both free and Pro plans. The limited free plan has a 500 MB monthly data limit and no additional features, but the Pro plan removes these limits. You can also choose between a slightly more expensive plan that covers all compatible operating systems or a cheaper option for just mobile devices.

ExpressVPN, while on the pricier side, offers significant discounts of up to 61%. With its long-term subscription, the monthly cost is $4.99/month, and it includes a few extra months of service for free. Given its speed, reliability, and strong security features, the higher price delivers far more value.

Winner

Which VPN offers better value for money? ExpressVPN, although slightly more expensive, is the one that gives you much more for the price. Plus, it frequently offers great deals and promotions, so you can usually get a good deal on your first subscription.

Our Methodology for Testing ExpressVPN vs Avira Phantom VPN

To ensure a fair comparison, we conducted thorough tests across multiple key areas. We assessed connection speeds on both local and international servers, evaluated streaming performance on popular platforms like Netflix and Disney+, and reviewed torrenting capabilities and privacy policies. We also compared their security features and abilities to work on restricted networks.

For a deep dive into our testing methods, visit our methodology page. Feel free to use our guidelines to perform your own testing.

ExpressVPN vs. Avira Phantom VPN — Reddit Opinions

ExpressVPN is frequently praised for its fast speeds and strong streaming capabilities. Redditors also appreciate its user-friendly interface, well-designed apps, and overall ease of use. Avira Phantom VPN, on the other hand, receives a fair amount of criticism. Many users express concerns about its security and privacy, with some even questioning its safety. However, some Redditors do consider it a reliable option for torrenting.